The vast majority of recoveries can be done with a kinetic rope and some soft shackles. The other piece of gear that I think everyone should have regardless of whether they are off-roading or not is jumper cables. So those items are my “required” recovery gear, and they rarely leave the back of my vehicle.
Everything else is situationally dependent. For example, if I’m wheeling alone (admittedly a bad idea, but I still do it) I’ll bring some recovery boards. If I’m going to an area that is more than a day’s walk away from civilization I’ll bring extra water, food, fire starter, etc. If I’m going to a dryer area of the country like the southwest I’ll bring a fire extinguisher so I don’t burn the entire forest down, etc etc.
It all depends on where I’m going, what I’m doing, and who I’m going with. And there are occasions where I leave behind gear to save in weight/space if I’ve coordinated with someone else in my group and I know they are bringing that piece of gear. If I’m going with a group of 8 vehicles, for example, probably don’t need to bring 8 shovels or 8 sets of recovery boards.
TL;DR— Your off to a good start and the suggestions others have made are awesome. Add a kinetic rope. ;)
2022 4dr Badlands, 2.3L Manual, Mid pkg
YouTube: youtube.com/@ragnarkon